Telenovela

     The amount of intrigue between the Philippine Dragon Boat Federation (PDBF) team and the Philippine Olympic Committee (POC) rivals that of our most watched telenovelas, but unlike them, this sporting controversy is not so clear-cut.

Who

Dragon Warriors: Victims?

     In most telenovelas, the audience knows who the protagonists and antagonists are, but in this case, it is muddled.  Are the PDBF rowers (Dragon Warriors) the victims and the POC, led by Chairman Peping Cojuangco the evil overlords?  Many are quick to point out yes, but the POC's recent media blitz is turning the tide.

     Here's the thing. First things first. What the POC did last year to the Dragon Boat Federation was pure crap.  If you need a blow by blow, I wrote about it here.  That clearly establishes the Dragon Warriors were victimized at least once and that also proves the POC has clearly been in the wrong.

     The more recent fight, though, is a lot less clear.  Dragon Warriors are certainly victims in the sense that they had no financial support from the POC and the Philippine Sports Commission (PSC), but the government, especially the PSC, is innocent here.  Under law, the PSC provides money only to the national teams, whose accreditation comes from the POC. (Why the spending of government money is dictated by a small private company is beyond me, but it's the law) This means that since the PBDF is not considered by the POC as a national team, they were not entitled to funding.  Now, PSC chairman Richie Garcia is as slimy as brown-nosers get, but this time he is not wrong.  The POC, meanwhile, is a different story.  The story gets sticky because of a memo from the International Olympic Committee (IOC).

What

     According to the POC, the IOC required (synonyms include mandated, forced) all countries to place Dragon Boat Federations under the Canoe and Kayak Associations. POC claims they had no choice but to move the PDBF or the country might face sanction and suspension.  On the other hand, the PDBF claims the IOC memo actually stated that countries may choose (country's prerogative, not required) to place Dragon Boat under Canoe and Kayak.  PDBF refused to be moved to the Philippine Canoeing and Kayaking Federation (PCKF); hence they were not recognized by the POC.

Why

     It begs the question then why both sides are insisting on fighting over this memo when the simpler thing is to compromise? 

     For the PBDF, it boiled down to two things.  One, moving under the PCKF meant that the current PDBF coaches will be not retained, for whatever reasons not made public.  Second, all International Dragon Boat races require that the teams be recognized by an accredited Dragon Boat Federation.  In the Philippines, that would only be the PDBF and not the PCKF.  Now, my only question is, wouldn't moving the PDBF into the PCKF mean that the PCKF can also be accredited by the International Dragon Boat Federation?

     For the POC, the reasons are quite murky, until you add creative thinking and deductive reasoning.  I have not hidden my disdain for the POC led by Cojuangco so a grain of salt must be taken with this following explanation.  First, the PBDF moving to PCKF means one less National Sports Association and one less vote in the POC elections.  The PCKF has always voted for the side of Cojuangco while the PDBF has not.  Think what you will.  Second, in their darkest hour, the Dragon Warriors found their savior in Cobra and PAL and were welcomed home in the Century Park Sheraton, all companies owned by magnate Lucio Tan.  Word from the grapevine is that someone helped the Dragon Warriors out with some introductions.  That someone is former PSC Chairman Harry Angping, whose term in PSC was highlighted by his strong stands against what he believed were wrong POC moves.  Again, think what you will.  

How

Cojuangco: Holding Aces

     President Aquino has stated that he would look into the matter, but it might not be a good idea.  Cojuangco holds two aces.  One and he has done this before, Peping can claim that anything Aquino does is political, snitch to the IOC and the IOC will suspend us if governments intervene in IOC affairs.  Second, removing Peping from sports gives him more free time to meddle in political matters.  During last year's campaign, Cojuangco volunteered to campaign for Aquino, but Aquino cringed at the idea.  He knows his uncle and the trail of bad publicity that follows him so he asked Cojuangco to back off.  That didn't stop Cojuangco from campaigning, which resulted in the whole "Noy-Mar" "Noy-Binay" controversy in Peping's native Tarlac.  It's not beyond belief that the best move for the PNoy is to get Peping out of his thinning hair by keeping him occupied in sports.  It won't be too surprising if the POC continues to have its way.  As much as I love sports, the country is a lot less worse if Peping meddled in sports and not congress, housing, land reform, poverty, agriculture or energy.

When

     As much as they are different, though, this Dragon Boat controversy and good telenovelas have something in common.  Both will last for quite some time since a resolution is either nowhere to be found or the resolution itself could open an even bigger can of worms for our struggling country.  We need to find a way to protect our athletes' and nations' interests, grab a hold of the problem and punch it smack on the chin.

Dragon Heart

     Many scoff at the 1996 movie Dragonheart, as a kid's movie, filled with action/adventure fluff and an entirely predictable happy ending.  While I won't dispute the fluff part, the movie's ending, where the evil and oppressive King Einan, is finally killed and defeated, is a sad one.  The hero, Bowen had to kill his best friend, Draco, the last remaining dragon on Earth, so that Einan will lose invincibility and die. Everyone was happy with the new peaceful kingdom, and some even happy that Draco would now be in heaven, but I couldn't believe no one felt sad or even noticed that all dragons became extinct.

     Everyone interested has probably heard or read about the story by now.  In 2010, in the run up to the South East Asian (SEA) Games, the Philippine Dragon Boat Federation (PDBF) Team was vying for slots to the Philippine delegation.  Coming in as two-time world champions, the team expected to receive a free pass, but the Philippine Olympic Committee, headed by Jose Peping Cojuangco, told them they had to earn them.  Asked to match the bronze medal times of the previous Asian Championships in order to qualify, the team performed in POC-arranged and sactioned time trials in La Mesa Dam (a POC-approved and utilized venue for Dragon Boat competitions).  In the time trials, the women's team performed times good enough for 2 gold medals and 1 silver, while the men's team performed times that could net a gold, silver and bronze.  In a completely head-scratching decision,  the POC representative, Col. Jeff Tamayo (ret.) claimed that the paddlers were, "super men and super women" or on "super steroids."  Not minding that the POC themselves arranged the time trials, Tamayo also  claimed that the PDBF  intentionally submitted slow reference times so they could overcome them. Of course, Tamayo could have just logged on to the internet to check the times himself, but that would make too much sense.  Tamayo recommended leaving the Dragon Boaters off the list of athletes for the SEA Games and the POC accepted it wholeheartedly.     

     After a media blitz (only in papers and blogs -- i posted one here and here), the POC was not through with the PDBF.  Pouncing on an International Olympic Committee (IOC) memo suggesting that Dragon Boat could be placed under Canoe and Kayak to keep things simple, claimed it was a directive from the IOC and it must be followed. Here's where it got real sticky.  The move to the Philippine Canoeing and Kayaking Federation (PCKF) would mean that the team will lose their existing coaches (who spoke against the POC - what a coincidence!!!) and they would lose their chance to compete in the World Championships since the PCKF is not recognized as a proper Dragon Boat Federation.  The team was stripped of its national team status as they refused to come under the PCKF; hence the loss of their athletes' salary and incentives.  


     As the Philippine Dragon Boat Federation Team comes home this week, the public has been properly informed of their amazing 5 gold, 2 silver romp in the recently concluded 10th IDBF Dragon Boat World Championships in Florida.  If everything goes as planned, they will receive a heroes' welcome from a grateful nation, their victory despite lack of funding and support from the Philippine Olympic Committee, serves as the nation's version of killing Einan.  The thing is, as the people celebrated Einan's defeat (rightfully so), no one bothered to remember that they had lost all the dragons.  We cannot afford to be like that.  


     As our dragons come home, we must welcome them with the love, support and adulation that they deserve, but we must also take care to be vigilant, to make sure that this amazing 5 gold and 2 silver romp will not be the last. We need our dragons alive and paddling.  We need to fight to correct the system that relegated them to near extinction and topple the oppresive evil that created it.




photos courtesy of Den Victoria